Mission Yearbook: Mystical reading opens new paths to encounter God, author says

Of all the ways we can read the Bible, the mystics offer us one that can help us encounter and experience God in ways other traditions can’t.

Carl McColman, a speaker, teacher and retreat leader who recently published “Read the Bible like a Mystic: Contemplative Wisdom and the Word,” was a recent guest of Simon Doong, host of “A Matter of Faith: A Presby Podcast.” Their 56-minute conversation can be heard here.

Image

Carl McColman appeared last week on "A Matter of Faith: A Presby Podcast."

In his book, McColman suggests four interpretive ways of reading Scripture: the literalist approach, an agnostic or atheist approach, the historical-critical approach used by many Presbyterians, and the mystical approach based on “the writings and teachings of Christian writers and thought leaders we have called mystics,” McColman said. “What they offer us is this fourth hermeneutical approach which in many ways weaves the best of the other three.”

“Contemplatives would say they ask the hard questions so they can wrestle with their faith and be invited deeper,” he said. “It’s anchored in seeking that relationship with the Holy, the Mystery, without any negativity toward the gift of scholarship and the historical-critical method.”

Theologians dating back to Origen stressed that reading the Bible is “about bringing love and grace, freedom, mercy and kindness into the world,” McColman said, citing as an example the distinction conservative and progressive Christians see in the taxonomy of sin.

“In conservative world, sin is a personal dynamic,” McColman said. “The salvation Jesus offers is deliverance from those personal failings. On the liberal side, it’s more academically informed, more cognizant of the role that psychology, sociology and cultural forces play in our personal behavior. It de-emphasizes the need for personal conversion and is more of a pushback against systemic sin,” including racism, sexism, homophobia and transphobia, and economic injustice.

“Conservatives focus on the individual’s program for self-improvement or self-healing and give the system a pass,” he said. “Liberals tend to do it the other way around. Really, the biblical text fires on both those cylinders.”

Image

While McColman said he’s a member of the progressive camp both theologically and philosophically and is “very sympathetic to how we struggle for justice and dismantle the systems of oppression and privilege,” there is “still the question, if there is a God, what does it mean for me and my heart to encounter the living God, and how does that make a difference in my life?”

“It’s less about what our thermostat will be set on in eternity,” he said, “and it’s more about how do I enter into a transformed life here and now? That’s where the mystics challenge all of us, whether you identify as conservative or progressive. Maybe we all need a more robust definition of what spirituality is.”

Part of that has to do with “this paradox of interior transformation and also social revolution, this idea that the Spirit of God calls us into a revolutionary society, the Beloved Community, a society based on love and kindness and kinship and relationship,” he said.

“For people of goodwill, the text lands in different ways,” McColman told Doong, and that’s why it’s best to interpret the Bible in community and not individually.

“There’s this bedrock principle that church happens in community,” he said. “That doesn’t mean there isn’t space for that individual experience. It’s a kind of tension. We need the individual encounter with the Mystery, but we also need the community to hone and form and shape our best practices as people of faith.”

“Who gets to decide? We have to decide together,” McColman said. “There has to be communal discernment.”

McColman believes the missing “secret sauce” in many progressive churches with, for example, a membership that’s aging is “that personal challenge. How are you giving your life to the spirit of love, the spirit of Christ, the spirit of holiness? How is this making a difference, and how can it help transform and heal society?”

New editions of “A Matter of Faith: A Presby Podcast” drop every Thursday. Listen to previous installments here.

Mike Ferguson, Editor, Presbyterian News Service (Click here to read original PNS Story)

Let us join in prayer for:

Mark DeSantis, Vice President, IT Infrastructure & Security, Information Technology, Board of Pensions
Ann DeVilbiss,  Production Associate, Publishing & Editorial, Presbyterian Publishing Corporation 

Let us pray:

Christ, we thank you for being the Word made flesh. As you ministered to those around you through touch, sight and sound, teach us to make use of our whole selves — body, mind and spirit—to do your work. Give us the courage to act and the grace to welcome all with a loving spirit. Amen.